(OT) Re: Bonding with crossover cables?

Aaron Grewell agrewell
Mon Dec 19 13:02:09 PST 2005


> A review would be nice (of the movie, I'm sure church will be fine...).
> We're either seeing that, or Harry Potter, for our family Christmas day
> movie.

I liked both of them, but I guess it depends on whether you are a fan of any 
of the books.  They changed Narnia less, but then it's an easier thing to 
replicate on-screen (much shorter and less complex).  Narnia is seriously 
effects-dependent (not that they really had a choice) and there are a few 
spots where it looked like those new 3D Coke commercials.  They spent a lot 
of time on the battle scenes, though, and those are really pretty cool.  I 
especially liked the Centaur who never seemed to run out of swords.  The only 
really major change I noted was that the directors were kinder to Edmund than 
Lewis was.

The new HP was good, better than Azkaban I thought.  Substantial changes had 
to be made in order to fit it all in, but if you aren't a regular Rowling 
reader then that's not going to bother you.  It's a bit scarier than the 
others, so if your children are sensitive to that sort of thing stick with 
Narnia.  I wouldn't take a child under 10 to Goblet without serious 
consideration.  I didn't have any trouble staying awake, but then I like 
fantasy in general and HP in particular so that's to be expected.

In short, both good but edge to Narnia because it's less likely to disturb 
small children (Aslan's death notwithstanding - after all it isn't permanent) 
and because it's not part 4 in a series you haven't seen the rest of.


More information about the Linux-users mailing list